O Happy Fault!

I lost my virginity in college.

It’s not a part of my journey that I’m bragging about or proud of—far from it.  In fact, for a long time I kept this in the dark and it was a major source of personal shame and embarrassment.  But it’s an essential element of my story from which I’ve personally experienced the mercy that God offers to every person, even to the most stubborn of sinners (that’s me).

It wasn’t planned.  I was never the “player” in school.  I was the “nice guy,” I attended my high school youth group, and I always thought I would wait until marriage before “crossing that line.”  But like a frog in a boiling pot that is oblivious to the heat being risen around it, sin got the best of me when I let down my guard (St. Paul warns us that “whoever thinks he is standing secure should take care not to fall,” or as the prophet Han Solo put it, “Don’t get cocky”).  The “line” got pushed further, and further, until one night in college it went too far.

Sin, as philosopher Peter Kreeft says, “makes us phonies.”  Sin steals our humanity, kills our joy, and leaves us as empty shells of true selves.  The character Gollum from The Lord of the Rings embodies the deteriorating effect that sin has upon us.  Gollum’s very body has become corrupted by his idolization of the Ring (his “precious”), an object that is the very impetus of his misery and despair.  He is addicted.  His senses are dulled and vision blackened.  Sin does the same to us.   Pre-marital sex, while idolized by the world and packaged as “real love,” is actually the opposite, as I found out first hand.  Rather than being free to love, I became enslaved to lust.  With darkened intellect and twisted desires, I rationalized.  I made up excuses for my behavior.   I never was further from “myself” and from God than in that period of my life.  I feared bringing any details of the relationship to the light.  So, like Gollum, I stayed in the darkness.

But darkness can never overcome the light.

“O happy fault!”  The phrase felix culpa (Latin for “happy fall” or “blessed guilt”) that we proclaim at the Easter Vigil fleshes out this wonderful paradox—through some of the greatest evils, God can pour out a greater love and mercy upon mankind.  St. Paul affirms this in his letter to the Romans: where sin abounds, grace abounds all the more (Romans 5:20).  From Adam’s sin came the glory of Jesus Christ.  From my own sin and selfishness, God mercifully cleansed and humbled me in the years of seminary formation to form me into the spouse I would one day become.

For a while, though, I lost hope in a happy ending to my story.  I thought I was “tainted” or “damaged goods.”  I didn’t know Jackie was coming (if I had, I would never have left my room!).  She’s been saving herself for marriage, and I had to confess to her that I didn’t.  I messed up.  But the way that Jackie loves me—in such a pure, disinterested, and benevolent way—has brought so much healing.  She told me one night that she doesn’t want the “Bobby of 2007” or the “Bobby of 2010;” she wants the “Bobby of now.”  I’ve been to confession.  I’ve been made a new creation.   And it was time to start living like it.

The band Mumford & Sons has a song off their latest album called “Lover of the Light.” It illustrates well how goodness trumps selfishness and how beauty dispels the shadows that enslave our hearts (even the music video depicts a blind man who runs freely out of his darkness into the freedom of the light).  No matter how long we’ve been living in the shadows, we are all called to be “lovers of the light.”  A part of my story that I kept in the dark for many years has been transformed into a testimony that I’m now sharing (through Jackie’s support) with teens and young adults.  One teen recently wrote us and said that our witness to her Confirmation group convicted her to keep her virginity even though her boyfriend was pressuring her to give it away to him.  Praise God!  Even if one young person turns back to God’s light because of our humble witnessing, this is all worth it.

I read recently that, “conversion involves the transformation of all our fragmented experiences, all our disjointed and painful memories, all our divisive and frustrating moments of unachieved hopes, yearning and dreams, failures and loss of self-esteem or sense of worth resulting from the destructive power of evil” (M. Gaudoin-Parker).

No one is ever “too far gone.”  Some of the greatest sinners have become the greatest saints.  God is calling all of us out of the darkness and into the light.  He wants to use our faults and failings for His glory.  Let’s give Him permission to do so.


  One thought on “O Happy Fault!

  1. March 5, 2013 at 8:08 pm

    God bless you, both, So wonderful!

  2. M
    March 6, 2013 at 1:52 am


  3. March 6, 2013 at 6:38 am

    I find that by being able to practice chastity helps us in the long run, especially when we age w/our marriage partner & can no longer “perform” physically/sexually…Chastity helps u “love” one another in SEVERAL POSSIBLE ways besides the obvious — that’s jst 1 of God’s Gift to us, HIs faithful followers… AmeN!

  4. Jen
    March 13, 2013 at 6:48 am

    Thank you for this, Bobby. I too lost my virginity towards the end of college and about a year later, I am still dealing with the devastating effects. Ironically (or shall we say through divine intervention) exactly when I was reading about the song “lover of the light” it started playing on Spotify. This post and that song were a sweet reminder of the beautiful invitation of Christ that I desperately needed to be reminded of. Thank you again for your humble testimony.

  5. fabio Rodrigez
    April 11, 2013 at 12:09 pm

    I lost my virginity in 8th grade, its been tough but i have seen the light through this.

  6. Aussiegal
    May 31, 2013 at 4:44 pm

    Thank you for sharing your story, which is really a story of our great Saviour. I can relate to your story, and lived with the heavy and suffocating weight of shame for many years. I went to confession and did feel ‘better’ as a result, although not fully healed. I wonder if the relief I felt was because I had allowed ‘light to penetrate the darkness’. Sexual sin is easily hidden and any secret including sexual sin has a way of eating your soul.

    I still however struggled with forgiving myself for many years. I was concerned about how others would judge me, and how my past sin would impact any future relationships. I was all too aware that sexual sin leaves its trail of devastation on self-esteem and identity.

    But praise be to our loving Lord and Father, that he has been at work in my life through his Spirit changing and conforming me into the likeness of his Son. I have learnt that Jesus’ death on the cross was and is sufficient, that he once and for all paid the penalty for my disobedience and sin. To continue to hold onto my shame and pain, is to deny Christ’s sacrifice for me. It would be akin to me saying, ‘you died for the sins of all mankind, but your death was not sufficient for me’. Now that is both arrogant and a lie!

    What healing we can have from a deep knowledge and understanding of the truth of Christ. I praise God for the work he has done in you also.

  7. Klink
    July 7, 2013 at 8:15 pm

    Wow this is so powerful, I have to admit that I too lost my virginity before marriage and continued to sin only to find that something was missing in my life and in my relationships. I found that it was God!! I have been missing the love and guidance of our loud most high. And since turning back to God and loving him with all my heart I am full fill and don’t need that little satisfaction to control my life anymore. I am waiting to share my new life with whomever God has chosen for me. I am very thankful that God has chosen you two to share your story and be translators for God as I and many more people look to you for guidance in our lives!!! Thank You!!!

  8. Zac
    July 29, 2013 at 7:17 pm

    Well said good sir. Thank you for your story and your bravery. May God bless you and yours all the days of your life. Peace, Zac

  9. September 23, 2014 at 2:20 pm

    I fell, too, and was so ashamed, not to mention self abuse since i was a small child. It is a struggle

  10. Tanya
    October 9, 2014 at 7:48 am

    I wish someone had come to talk at my school as a teen, on the real reasons why to wait…Thank-you for your courageous testimony!

  11. AdventuresofEsmerelda
    October 16, 2014 at 6:02 am

    I loved this and needed this! I am a 26 year old virgin by choice, and it is hard! But I know it be worth it, and I just needed to red you and your wife’s stories for added encouragement! Thank you so much!

  12. November 24, 2014 at 9:41 pm

    Thank you for sharing – I sent my prayers for you both and also for your family.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: